Wednesday, March 2, 2011

Do they have a "What to expect...the Elementary school years" book, yet?

This is somewhat of a difficult subject for me to blog about for several reasons. First of all, it's just unpleasant to talk about and painful to think about, because it's my child it's happening to. Secondly, there is no way to prove what exactly is going on because what goes on between 7 & 8 year old girls on the playground stays between 7 & 8 year old girls on the playground. And third, I think that every mother out there has a "mama bear" instinct deep inside them and when things like this happen you want to march right into school with your kid and demand that something be done about this issue but you just can't and that is not how I want to teach my daughter to deal with these issues. So It is a difficult subject in and of itself but particularly difficult to write about for me because I am not used to writing about serious topics. I like to keep it light and fun. However, I think it is one that will have to be addressed in every household at some point or another and that's why I thought I would talk about it on my blog this morning.

My 7 year old daughter Cate is in 1st grade. She moved to this public school this year after spending 2 years at a private Christian school in Cedartown. It was not a decision that we made lightly but financial strains and moving so far away from her old school kind of made the decision for us. Cate never had one best friend at her old school, but she seemed to like everyone in her class and she never said anything about anyone being mean to her or excluding her. Of course, preschool and kindergarten are different. I don't think I ever felt excluded or picked on until at least the first grade. While Cate is in the first grade, she is in a multi-age class with first AND second graders. I thought that this might happen, Cate feeling left out because the second graders had formed friendships last year and already had established "cliques" which would leave out the 1st graders. By the first month or so of school, I had already heard about this one second grader who was...oh how shall we say this? A snot nosed little brat who enjoys making other people feel bad? Yeah, that's about right. And Cate seems to be her "target". We'll call this kid "Susie"(there is no susie in her class and the kids name does not start with an S or end with a -ie so if you are reading this and are a parent of a kid in my kids class, just know that).

Some of the things Cate came home with were just silly. For example, once she hopped into the car and said "Susie made so & so not like me today" *eye roll*. "Cate, Susie cannot make anyone not like you, and if so&so decided not to like you because Susie told her not to like you, you don't want to be friends with so&so anyway because she is not a good friend" Most of the time, the complaints are things like that. And we have a discussion about it and Cate feels better and we keep on living our lives. Lately, everything has centered around Susie. Susie made fun of Cate's clothes, Susie accused Cate of spitting on her, Susie said this and that and everything else she could possibly think of to hurt my daughters feelings or upset her. I am just about sick of Susie. While there is a still a part of me that wants to give Susie the benefit of a doubt, I cannot have Cate thinking that I do not believe her, so I am trusting her that what she says is happening in indeed what is happening.

Now...There are a lot of emotions that go through a mom when you see your baby upset by other's actions. You feel sympathy, you feel anger, you feel sad, you feel helpless, and then you feel angry even more, and then more helplessness. Cate is a good kid. I know all parents must say that about their children, but she is a pretty good kid. She tries not to leave others out, but being left out is something she is going to have to come to terms with. It's part of life and you cannot always demand to be included and cry when you are not. I sympathize with the pain of being excluded because that was the story of my school years. I never had many close friends. I played by myself on the playground many times during my elementary school years. My senior year of highschool, I sat at a lunch table by myself because I didn't have 1 friend on that lunch shift. Not one. I would read or pretend to study so that it looked like I was secluding myself on purpose, lol. I get it! I really do, but that's life sometimes and you just have to make the most of it and you can't spend your entire life with your arms crossed pouting about how unfair everyone treats you. And being excluded is not bullying. It might not  be very kind, but it's not bullying. It's life. I can deal with that, I can teach HER to deal with that. Where I am struggling right now is with the other parts that I do not want her to just "accept".

Cate has been taught that when people are ugly to her, she should ignore them and walk away. Susie has never physically harmed Cate, as far as I know and I honestly don't suspect that she ever would. She is a snot to be sure, but not violent. However, Susie is constantly making Cate feel ugly, unintelligent, and unwanted by her peers. This is very hurtful to me. As I said, Cate is a good kid for the most part. She isn't perfect, but she isn't mean either. I think she is beautiful, and we have told her that every day of her life and suddenly she hates her hair and her big teeth. She reads beautifully at home but her teacher insists that she is not reading well at school. It makes me angry. It makes me want to grab Susie's mom by the shoulders and scream "What the hell did you do to raise such a mean little girl!" The point of matter is this: You don't have to teach kids to be mean, but you do have to teach them to be kind. They don't learn to be selfish, but they have to learn to be giving. You don't have to show them to be spiteful, but you have to SHOW them how to be gracious and forgiving.*for the record, I have met Susies mother and she is a perfectly lovely lady and very sweet so I do not think she is being taught to be a bully*

I would never have a problem intervening if Susie were physically harming Cate and I had evidence to prove that Susie is being a bully. I have explained this to Cate, Cate understands(or so she says). It's hard when your baby comes to you for advice and all you have to give them is the whole "What would Jesus Do" speech, but it's what we have to work with. Being spiteful might make her feel better but it makes her no better than Susie if she goes that route. One day someone is going to deck Susie and teach her a lesson but it won't be my kid. Cate and I had a long talk about "Susie" yesterday and I think I finally got through. She heard the "forgiveness" part, and the "turn the other cheek" thing, but I think what she took away from the whole conversation was "kill them with kindness"....do'h, almost. I ALMOST got through.

I remember the pain and agony of growing up, and as soon as I finally made it past those horrible years of self discovery, I became a mother and now I have to watch my daughter go through it. I never imagined that it would be so hard to guide her through this, or that it would hurt so bad when I can't fix it. One thing parenting will do for you, it will make you get really used to praying when you don't know what else to do...cause when you are a parent, you have to do SOMETHING.

(this morning, face painted for Dr. Seuss day at school--and little brother had to paint his too!)
Picture 009

A very cliche song, but I do like it :-)

9 comments:

Mimi said...

Love the post title....made me chuckle.

We are going through similar situation with Dylon, although it is more about athleticism amongst a few boys that he desperately wants to be accepted by. I know part of it all is just growing up, but it just sucks when we do our part as parents to ensure we are raising the best person possible, to treat others fairly and with a kind heart and then they get slapped in the face by a kid who isn't taught the same. I have the same thoughts of shaking the mothers.....but in the end, I find myself praying for the heart of the children who are not taught values and humanity. Over their lifetime, they'll end up on the short end of the stick by how they treat others.....

Hoping Cate discovers her beauty that others see very soon!!

April said...

You are so right Megan. The hardest part for me is leading by example. I always want to do the proper Christian thing, but I let my emotions get the best of me sometimes :-( I don't want her to feel resentful of other people, I don't want her to let other people make her doubt herself. I want her to defend herself, but not through revenge or retaliation. This kid, Susie, I am sure she is not a bad kid entirely. She is just a normal little girl who has found out that picking on someone else makes her feel cool and popular and better. Like I said, her mom is precious, and I doubt she is like this at home or her mother would nip that in the bud. And honestly, I can't prove that it's really going on! So I cannot accuse this child of anything. But "susie" isn't my problem, my responsibility is Cate and how she deals with it. People can only make her feel bad about herself as much as she allows them to. There will always be a "susie" in her life, she has to learn NOW how to protect herself from it. How she handles this first bully will change her forever, for good or bad. That's her choice, I just have to point her(or forcefully SHOVE her) in the proper direction.

Quietly Subversive said...

Exactly, April, I was going to say there's always going to be a "Susie." You beat me to it!

Particularly with girls, I think it's on us to raise self-confident girls that are secure enough in themselves that they will give the Susies of the world the metaphorical finger.

I'm so not to this stage yet with my daughter, but I do indeed dread it because my insecurity really comes out (I was one of those kids that just wanted to be liked and unsuccessfully tried to disguise it). It breaks my heart.

Mimi said...

So, so true. Cate is blessed to call you MOM :)

April said...

I did come to that realization after I posted this Beth! LoL. I was thinking "At least next year, Susie will have moved onto the 3rd grade and out of Cate's life...but sure as the world, there will be a new Susie to take the old one's place" Raising kids is hard!! Give me bottles and sleepless nights anytime over the junk...blech!

Mandi said...

Oh that brings back flashbacks to Bonnie's first grade year! We had tears every single night because of the perceived meanness and exclusion. I broke my heart into a million pieces. :-(
In the fourth grade when she started back to school, there was another Susie, and she still has problems in school now. I wish I had some advice to give you because I certainly struggle with teaching my kids to be kind and confident when confronted with meanness. I always try to tell her that if she befriends the friendless, she will have more friends than anyone.

joymom said...

Riley is having some of the same problems this year in kindergarten. There is one really "popular" girl who is also quite mean. Luckily she is not in the same class but playground drama happens almost every day and the tears flow here some days as well. It sounds like you are doing a fantastic job at comforting and providing advice and encouragement for Cate! (Our Suzie was in Riley's gymnastics class and I actually made a point to change Riley's class schedule to get her away from her....her family visited our church and I was secretly relieved that they have not visited again. I am really hoping they are not in different classes again next year as well.)

Tara said...

Your doing such an awesome job at trying to raise well rounded children.

I wish I could say "I've been there and I know what Cate is going through", but I have no advice. I think you have given great advice to hear already. This is how I try to raise my 3 and I think we're doing very good so far.

Tell Cate she is a very beautiful little girl. The only reason Susie picks on her is because she's jealous. Cate has the inner and outer beauty and that's what is most important.

Tys said...

This was great to read April. I'm having a rough time right now, Jake's only 4, and I'm starting to doubt I have the balls for parenting.

Jake was being physically harmed by this one kid. Well enough of a ruckus was caused in the playgroup that he no longer physically bullies Jake but now he makes the other kids not play with Jake :(

I feel at such a loss. He was getting rejected over and over and over again... and when he'd tried to go off on his own this horrible little kid (I know I'm a bad person) followed him to keep the whole tease/rude thing going on.

I wanted to cry. I don't know what to do. I'm never going to survive the middle school high school years if I can't even make it past age FOUR.

Followers

Blog Archive